Real Women Have Curves, And Don’t Have Curves, And Have…

Which of these women is more real? Kate Moss or Beth Ditto?

by Golda Poretsky, H.H.C.

Lot’s of very well meaning people, when they find out what I do for a living, say something to the effect of:

Real Women Have Curves: The Movie

“Right on!  Real women have curves!”

 

I know they mean well.  They’re saying that women’s bodies are more curvaceous than the emaciated bodies that are often held as an ideal by the media.  But the whole concept drives me bonkers.  And if it hasn’t driven you bonkers yet, let me explain why it drives me bonkers and you may end up agreeing with me.

1) Women Are Women, Curvy Or Not – Women’s bodies (just like men’s bodies) come in a diverse range of shapes.  There are plenty of curvy thin women and curvy fat women, not curvy thin women and not curvy fat women.  There are plenty of fat women with proportionately small hips and proportionately big hips.  There are plenty of thin women with the same.  Same for breasts.  Same for everything.  There are also some men with bigger hips and smaller hips and bigger breasts and smaller breasts.  In other words, there are plenty of “real women” who are not f-ing curvy and are still quite real, and sometimes even, quite fat.

2) What The Heck Is A Real Woman, And Why Should We Care? – Personally, I think that anyone who identifies as a woman is a woman.  I don’t really care if she has curves or a vulva or whatever.  I’m guessing that if you’re reading this blog, you probably don’t care to much about it either.  But aside from that, does it help anything to refer to larger women as “real”?  Does that make thin women fake?  Or not really women?  Ugh.  See item #4.

3) Can We Just Say FAT For Once? — I personally hate the curvy euphemism.  I hate it more than most

Which of these women is more real? Kate Moss or Beth Ditto?

others, like large or even plus size (though I agree with Queen Latifah that plus size should be “buried“).  Curviness has way more to do with chest/waist/hip ratio than anything else, and I think our fixation on those measurements has added to the negative way that most women view their bodies for decades.

4) Relegating Thin Women To A Lesser Status Isn’t Helpful – I realize that bigger women have been put down, discriminated against, considered non-ideal, and worse, and that is really, really wrong and needs to change.  But I don’t think the way to create that change is to try to prove that bigger is better.  How about we just start to see that bigger is great too. We don’t have to relegate ourselves to a scarcity model of beauty and “realness” belong to only a select few.  Perhaps one doesn’t have to be better than the other.  Perhaps we can see that there’s a thing called body diversity, that beauty comes in all shapes and sizes, and that attraction is viable among people of varying weights.

So, yes, real women have curves, and don’t have curves, and whatever, at least that’s what I think.  Let me know what you think in the comments section below!

Golda Poretsky, H.H.C. is a certified holistic health counselor who specializes in transforming your relationship with food and your body. Go to http://www.bodylovewellness.com/stay-in-touch/ to sign up for her newsletter and get your free download — Golda’s Top Ten Tips For Divine Dining!

Cross-posted with permission; Original piece from www.bodylovewellness.com

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Post to Twitter

Music’s New Bold and Bountiful

Beth Ditto rocks her curves on two magazine covers
Ditto rocks her curves for not one, but two magazine covers.

Ditto rocks her curves for not one, but two magazine covers.

“I’ve proven you don’t have to be some skinny girl to do well,” says Adele, an up-and-coming solo soul tinged pop artist. It’s not a statement heard commonly today in music.

Adele, a 21-year-old from England, is quickly becoming renowned for her impressive vocal range and soulful voice. The singer’s debut album released in early 2008 has topped the charts in the UK and North America. The 2008 BRIT Awards appointed her as the Critics’ Choice and in 2009, she captured two Grammy awards, Best New Artist and Best Female Pop Vocal Performance. What’s even more is that in June of this year she co-headlines with her idol, the iconic Etta James.

Beth Ditto, originally from Arkansas, is the 28-year-old lead singer for the band Gossip. She’s captured headlines and wowed fans in the world of indie rock and punk for her incredible vocals, often likened to those of Janis Joplin and Aretha Franklin. At the 2008 Glamour Awards, she won International Artist of the Year. The openly gay singer gained even more exposure in the US and abroad for penning and performing the hit single “Standing in the Way of Control,” which rails against the American government’s decision to ban same-sex marriage.

Adele and Ditto each boast substantial fan bases that continue to grow, but not only due to their outstanding talent: Their admirers appreciate them for their authenticity. Neither is interested in projecting a cookie-cutter image to the public. Adele states that, “I’m not going to start changing and becoming something I’m not.” Ditto echoes the same sentiment by saying,

“I spent so much of childhood trying to change, and I just got sick of it … I don’t want to look like Britney Spears.”

The voluptuous stars don’t apologize for their size. In fact, both are outspoken about their refusal to diet. Adele’s bio on her US website asserts, “My aim in life is never to be skinny.” Ditto takes it one step further explaining how she no longer uses the word “overweight” to describe herself because it “sets a standard for people to be.” Rather, she prefers the term “fat,” not for “insult or degradation” but as an honest description of who she is: “the truth is that I am fat and that’s okay.”

Ditto is not alone in her views. Actually, some think that her size is a lot more than okay. In February 2009, she donned the cover of the UK fashion magazine Love wearing nothing but dramatic eye make-up and black lipstick. And the publication didn’t stop there. Should you want a closer look at the glamorous singer (or to see exactly what her tattoos say), check out Love‘s website where you can magnify Ditto and all her beauty by simply rolling your mouse over her photo. This isn’t the first time she’s demonstrated her boldness by posing nude. Britain’s New Musical Express (NME) celebrated the singer by capturing her confidence and bare body on its June 2007 cover, which incidentally was nominated for the award of UK’s Best Magazine Cover.

But not all of the media is nearly as supportive of plus-sized talent as are Love and NME. Although Adele isn’t interested in undressing for the camera, she’s been recently showcased in Vogue‘s annual Shape Issue under the heading of “Curvy.” Apparently though, the photo taken by Annie Leibovitz contained too many curves for Vogue‘s liking. The publication photoshopped out much of Adele, resulting in an image that vaguely resembles the singer’s full figure. This blatant distortion of her body reflects mainstream media’s general uneasiness with talented folk who also happen to be fat. Evidence of this fact continues to be illustrated in interviews with the singers, who must repeatedly field questions about their weight.

Whether we like it or not, music in the 21st century isn’t only about the sound. It’s also what we see, be it on television, in print, or live. The images that accompany today’s music, at least when it comes to female performers, fall within narrow parameters. But with singers like Adele and Ditto challenging these norms, with any luck we might be on the edge of a shift in the music industry–one that accepts talent in all shapes and sizes.

Related content:

The Truth About Celebrity Weight Loss

Margaret Cho on Drop Dead Diva and the Power of Reclaiming Beauty

Three Cheers for Kate!

‘Sex and the City’ and Body Image

Annoying Trend: Celebs Play Dumb About Body Image

Michael Jackson: Another Victim of the Fame Game

Lady Gaga’s “Born This Way”: Racist or Revolutionary?

Body image gets animated: What The Simpsons and Family Guy say about beauty

Post to Twitter

Move Over Barbie, Now There’s Something Meatier

Real Woman Barbie, the Ditto Version

Real Woman Barbie, the Ditto Version

Vogue UK wrote this piece for their website on the new “Wouldn’t It Be Nice” Barbie doll version of musician Ditto.

WHAT does Beth Ditto have in common with Barbie? The answer: more than you think. In keeping with fashion’s recent preoccupation with dolls (Roksanda and Gareth Pugh designed outfits for Barbie and Ken, respectively), Ditto’s curves have been translated into pint-sized proportions to give a sneak peek of her collection for Evans, with hits stores in July.

Superdoll Collectables London created the one-off doll, which is set to make an appearance in the Rankin campaign imagery of the collection. So what can we expect from Ditto’s design team? A capsule range full of slouchy, rock-inspired clothes and accessories with enough sparkle to give Barbie a run for her money.

Julia Neel

Related Content:

The False Mirror: On Diversity, Bizarre Barbies, and Body Image Activism

Dolls: It Matters If You’re Black or White

Barbie’s Plummeting Neckline Causes Uproar

I’m Saving My Cheers Over New “Authentic” Black Barbie Line

Barbie’s Ankles Too Fat for Louboutin’s Stylelist Fashion Blog

A Picture Worth a Thousand Words

Joan Holloway Barbie Proves Plastic is Less Fantastic

Post to Twitter